Probative Blindness and False Assurance about Safety
نویسندگان
چکیده
Safety activities may provide assurance of safety even where such assurance is unwarranted. This phenomenon – which we will call “probative blindness” – is evident both in hindsight analysis of accidents and in the daily practice of safety work. The purpose of this paper is to describe the phenomenon of probative blindness. We achieve this by distinguishing probative blindness from other phenomena, identifying historical instances of probative blindness, and discussing characteristics and causes associated with these instances. The end product is an explanation of the features of probative blindness suitable for investigating the probative value of current safety activities, and ultimately for reducing the occurrence of probative blindness.
منابع مشابه
Probative Blindness: How Safety Activity can fail to Update Beliefs about Safety
Accidents are preceded by a period where, in hindsight, there was an opportunity to recognise and prevent the impending disaster. Various theories have attempted to describe and explain why warning signs are ignored. This paper examines the specific role of safety analysis as a warning mechanism. Depending on the context of the analysis, and the selection of activities, safety analysis may only...
متن کاملInterviewing children versus tossing coins: accurately assessing the diagnosticity of children's disclosures of abuse.
We describe a Bayesian approach to evaluating children's abuse disclosures and review research demonstrating that children's disclosure of genital touch can be highly probative of sexual abuse, with the probative value depending on disclosure spontaneity and children's age. We discuss how some commentators understate the probative value of children's disclosures by: confusing the probability of...
متن کاملA Safety-II Perspective on Organisational Learning in Healthcare Organisations; Comment on “False Dawns and New Horizons in Patient Safety Research and Practice”
In their recent editorial Mannion and Braithwaite provide an insightful critique of traditional patient safety improvement efforts, and offer a powerful alternative vision based on Safety-II thinking that has the potential to radically transform the way we approach patient safety. In this commentary, I explore how the Safety-II perspective points to new directions for organisational learning in...
متن کاملJohn T . Wixted and Laura Mickes Characteristic Analysis The Field of Eyewitness Memory Should Abandon Probative Value and Embrace Receiver Operating
Clark (2012) highlights an important issue that has received inadequate attention in the eyewitness memory literature: lineup procedures that reduce the false identification rate (a desirable effect) often tend to reduce the correct identification rate as well (an undesirable effect). Determining which procedure is diagnostically superior under those conditions is not easy. Clark (2012) showed ...
متن کاملWhen ' neutral ' evidence still has probative value ( with implications from
The likelihood ratio (LR) is a probabilistic method that has been championed as a ‘simple rule’ for evaluating the probative value of forensic evidence in court. Intuitively, if the LR is greater than one then the evidence supports the prosecution hypothesis; if the LR is less than one it supports the defence hypothesis, and if the LR is equal to one then the evidence favours neither (and so is...
متن کامل